Modern Web Guidance

Search hidden content

Web interfaces often hide content from view to improve the user experience, save screen space, or increase page performance. Traditional methods like display: none or visibility: hidden work to hide content visually, but they also make that content completely inaccessible to screen readers and browser features like "Find in page".

To hide content visually but still allow it to be searchable by users and enable it to be deep linked to via URL fragments and "Scroll to Text Fragment" links, you can use either the HTML <details> element or the hidden="until-found" attribute. The <details> element is generally recommended as it's simpler to implement and maintain, but there are some more complex cases where <details> is not sufficient and hidden="until-found" is required.

For example:

• If you want full control over the styling of the show/hide mechanism.

• If the UI controls to show/hide the content are in another part of the DOM.

• If you don't want to support hiding the content after it's shown.

How to implement

The <details> element has searchable and accessible text by default, and no special implementation is required. Prefer using <details> over hidden="until-found" if possible.

If you need to use hidden="until-found" instead, follow these instructions:

1. Apply the attribute: Add the hidden="until-found" HTML attribute directly to the elements containing the content that should be hidden from view.

2. Synchronize UI state: If the interface has related states that depend on the content's visibility (e.g., updating ARIA attributes, toggling open/close CSS classes, or rotating accordion icons):

   • You MUST add an event listener for the beforematch event.

   • Register the beforematch event listener directly on the element carrying the hidden="until-found" attribute. Since the event bubbles, you may alternatively use event delegation by registering a single listener on a parent element (such as a tab container) to manage multiple hidden sections at once.

   • Inside the event listener, execute the logic to synchronize related UI elements (such as closing other open tabs or changing the state of a toggle button).

Example code

Goal: Render a hidden container where the content remains invisible to the user until they search for a word within that section.

Using <details> element

<details>
  <summary>Click to expand</summary>
  <p>This content is visually hidden.</p>
</details>

Mutually exclusive disclosures

When handling mutually exclusive content regions, like an exclusive accordion, use the native HTML <details> element with a shared name attribute.

<div class="accordion-group">
  <!-- The name attribute creates an exclusive disclosure group -->
  <details class="disclosure" name="my-accordion">
    <summary>Section 1</summary>
    <p>Section 1 content</p>
  </details>

  <details class="disclosure" name="my-accordion" open>
    <summary>Section 2</summary>
    <p>Section 2 content</p>
  </details>

  <details class="disclosure" name="my-accordion">
    <summary>Section 3</summary>
    <p>Section 3 content</p>
  </details>
</div>

Using hidden="until-found" attribute

<!-- The browser automatically removes hidden="until-found" upon a search match -->
<div class="hidden-container" hidden="until-found">
  <p>This content is visually hidden.</p>
</div>

Custom mutually exclusive disclosures

When handling custom mutually exclusive regions controlled by external buttons, ensure only the matched panel remains visible. In the beforematch event handler, you MUST synchronize related ARIA states such as setting aria-expanded="true" on the controlling button.

<div class="custom-accordion">
  <div class="controls">
    <button aria-expanded="true" aria-controls="panel-1" id="btn-1">Section 1</button>
    <button aria-expanded="false" aria-controls="panel-2" id="btn-2">Section 2</button>
  </div>

  <div id="panel-1" class="panel">
    <p>Section 1 content (visible)</p>
  </div>

  <div id="panel-2" class="panel" hidden="until-found">
    <p>Section 2 content (hidden)</p>
  </div>
</div>

const accordion = document.querySelector('.custom-accordion');

accordion.addEventListener('beforematch', (e) => {
  // Hide all panels and synchronize button states before the browser reveals the matched panel
  accordion.querySelectorAll('.panel').forEach((panel) => {
    if (panel !== e.target) {
      panel.hidden = 'until-found';
    }
  });
  accordion.querySelectorAll('button').forEach((btn) => {
    const controls = btn.getAttribute('aria-controls');
    btn.setAttribute('aria-expanded', controls === e.target.id ? 'true' : 'false');
  });
});

Best practices for hidden="until-found"

• DO apply borders, padding, and backgrounds to nested child wrappers rather than directly to the element with the hidden="until-found" attribute. This prevents unintended layout shifts or visual remnants while the element is hidden.

• DO NOT apply display: none, visibility: hidden, or any associated display or visibility CSS properties directly to elements with the hidden="until-found" attribute. This breaks the native functionality and permanently hides the content from the search index.

• DO NOT use hidden="until-found" for sensitive information, internal data tokens, or irrelevant data that should not be exposed via search.

• DO NOT use hidden="until-found" as a replacement for "screen reader only" (.sr-only) text.

Browser support and fallback strategies

The <details> element is Baseline Widely available, so a fallback strategy is not required.

The hidden="until-found" attribute is not yet Baseline Widely available, but it can be safely used with a fallback in unsupporting browsers. DO NOT avoid hidden="until-found" because of missing browser support, as its accessiblity benefits far outweigh the cost of implementing a fallback.

hidden="until-found" fallback

For standard UI elements like accordions or "Read more" sections, use JavaScript to feature-detect and show all content if the feature is unsupported.

if (!('onbeforematch' in HTMLElement.prototype)) {
  // Expand all hidden content for unsupported browsers
  document.querySelectorAll('[hidden="until-found"]').forEach((el) => {
    el.removeAttribute('hidden');
    // MANDATORY: also update any aria references to this element.
  });
}

For mutually exclusive UI paradigms (like custom exclusive panels where content shares the same visual region), the fallback should extract and display all content linearly below the main interactive area, using URL anchor fragments to allow users to navigate directly to the respective sections.